Vice Mayor Rhonda Anderson read the article over lunch.
It had been published shortly after noon on an anonymous blog and raised questions about Commissioner Melissa Castro’s travel expenses for a trip to Tallahassee. Then Anderson brought the matter before the City Commission and urged Castro to reimburse the city. Mayor Vince Lago followed with questions about receipts, travel dates, hotel charges and Uber expenses.
Castro said she had not seen the article.
“This is the first time that I’m hearing about it,” she told her colleagues. She disputed parts of Lago’s account, said she had personally paid some expenses and asked that the matter return as a scheduled agenda item so she could review the records.
“I don’t have the facts in front of me,” she said.
The commission took no action.
This board takes no position on whether Castro’s expenses were appropriate. Commissioners who suspect improper spending by a colleague have every right to raise it, and perhaps a duty.
Our objection is to the method.
The matter arrived as a pocket item, without notice on the commission’s published agenda. It was at least the second time in five weeks that a substantive matter reached the commission this way.
A pocket item is, in practice, a matter a commissioner raises without placing it on the posted agenda. It can give colleagues no time to study the issue, staff no time to assemble records and residents no reason to know they should attend the meeting.
Every commissioner has a better route. City code gives each member authority to sponsor and place items on the agenda, and the published agendas identify those items by sponsor. Giving notice costs a commissioner a few days of patience.
There is a legitimate place for the pocket item. A hurricane does not wait for an agenda deadline. Neither does an immediate public-safety threat or a legal deadline that expires before the next regular meeting.
A park name can wait.
Five weeks earlier, on Aug. 25, Lago introduced what he called “another pocket item” and proposed naming a future park associated with the Publix redevelopment at 2551 Le Jeune Road for City Manager Peter Iglesias.
As the Gazette wrote at the time, the commission violated no rule. The city’s park-naming policy allows the commission to waive its procedures.
That does not make bypassing those procedures good practice.
The city has a Parks and Recreation Advisory Board for a reason. Staff review and advisory-board consideration allow a proposal to be examined before commissioners vote. That process was used for parks honoring former Mayor Dorothy Thomson and James and Sallye Jude.
No emergency required immediate action on the Iglesias proposal. The park does not yet exist. The advisory board could have considered the name first.
The same principle applies with greater force when the subject is the conduct of another elected official.
Allegations about a colleague’s conduct deserve a higher standard. Except in a genuine emergency, they should appear on a posted agenda, with supporting records available in advance and a fair opportunity for the person involved to respond.
Once an allegation is aired from the dais, the lack of notice cannot be undone. A commissioner who learns of it there, with an anonymous blog post as the source, cannot answer with documents. She can ask for more time, as Castro did. The public exchange has already occurred.
Advance notice also protects the other commissioners. They should not be expected to assess accusations, financial records or policy questions for the first time while cameras are running and a meeting is underway.
And it protects residents.
A published agenda tells the public what its government intends to discuss and possibly decide. It allows residents to read the documents, contact commissioners, attend the meeting and speak before a decision is made.
Watching the video afterward is not participation.
The commission can solve the problem with a simple rule.
Any matter that can reasonably wait should wait for the next agenda. Short of an emergency, an unnoticed item may be raised for discussion, but substantive action should occur at the next properly noticed meeting. Allegations about a colleague’s conduct should wait for a posted agenda altogether.
The emergency exception should be narrow. If a commissioner believes immediate action is necessary, the sponsor should explain on the record why delay would materially harm the city, and four of the five commissioners should agree before the commission proceeds. Coral Gables already uses a four-fifths standard in other circumstances when commissioners are asked to waive normal requirements.
The city should also define an emergency in writing: an immediate threat to health, safety or property, or a legal deadline that falls before the next regular meeting.
Honorary names for parks and public facilities should go through the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board before reaching the dais. Allegations concerning a commissioner’s conduct should come through a posted agenda with the relevant records and, when warranted, be referred to the appropriate legal or ethics authority.
The clerk should also keep a public list of the pocket items raised at each meeting. Residents should be able to see how often this extraordinary procedure is used and for what purposes.
The practice belongs to no faction. In October 2023, immediately after a vote on commission compensation, then-Commissioner Kirk Menendez moved, as a non-agenda item, to censure Lago over what the resolution called “personal public comments attacking his colleagues and their families to the media and other outlets.” Castro and Commissioner Ariel Fernandez voted with him, and the resolution passed 3-2. In February 2024, while the commission was discussing how to fill the city manager vacancy, the same three commissioners appointed Amos Rojas Jr. city manager by the same 3-2 vote through a resolution the city recorded as a non-agenda item. The Gazette has identified no rule that either action violated. The principle applies regardless of who holds three votes: commissioners and residents should know in advance when substantive action is coming to a vote.
A commission needs some flexibility for genuinely unforeseen circumstances, and a stated reason with a supermajority vote provides it. The rule would bind all five members, including those who object to the practice today. A rule written for whoever holds the gavel will someday protect them, too.
Procedural protections are easiest to value when the other side needs them. Their real test comes when commissioners are frustrated, enthusiastic, offended or certain that they are right.
Agenda rules are restraints a government places upon itself. Without them, “pocket item” can become little more than a label for whatever five elected officials happen to want to discuss that day.
That is not how deliberative government should work.
The allegations concerning Castro’s travel expenses deserve an answer. The city’s next agenda now includes a discussion of travel expenses, sponsored by Castro herself.
That is how the matter should proceed: on a published agenda, with the relevant records available, Castro given a fair opportunity to respond, commissioners able to ask their questions and residents able to judge the evidence for themselves.
The process may take a little longer.
Good government sometimes should.
An agenda is a promise. When the commission posts one, it tells residents what to expect.
If a matter is important enough for the commission to debate or act upon, it is important enough for elected officials and residents to know about in advance, except in a genuine emergency.
Residents should expect that of their government.











Mayor Lago has been in office in his current position for the last 8 years and claims that he should be kept in office for an additional two years because he truly knows how to do his job. Based on the facts described in the current article, many citizens are likely to disagree. If anything, Mr. Lago’s behavior can be used to accurately describe him as a manager who is completely unable to perform his daily responsibilities.
Let us count the ways why it is time for Mr. Lago to pick up his bags and return full time to his job as a construction manager: 1) He makes decisions on impulse without seeking advise from the other members of the current administration. It must be pointed out that he is not Ms. Castro’s supervisor, but only his colleague. He is not authorized to call Ms. Castro on the carpet or discipline her. 2) Ms. Castro has not been given an opportunity to defend herself, something which even criminals in our judicial system are allowed to do. 3) No time has been given to Ms. Castro to hire a lawyer and conduct discovery, something which even criminals are permitted to do, 3) Mr. Lago’s actions smell of clear politics in action because he is exposing a criminal charge against a political opponent less that 30 days from a major election. For example, it is the practice of the US Federal Department of Justice not to consider accusation against a President when such an action will have a political impact on an election. 4) The charges in this case have been made by a party who is not a police or government official and whose accusations leave a lot to be desired because he is a rabid political follower of Mr. Lago. 5) The entire incident provides support for the accusation many have made that Mr. Lago is well known for fiercely attacking those with whom he politically disagrees.
All these factors lead me to conclude that I made the right decision when I announced earlier this year that I was running for Mayor of Coral Gables. There comes a time when people have a moral obligation to stand up firmly against abuses to our fellow citizens. I only hope that other citizens will agree with me and take this opportunity to also rise and say: “Enough is enough, Mr. Mayor.”
This is an excellent analysis of the situation by Mr. Cancio.
It’s shameful.
Enough has been enough for many years now.
We have not learned from the past mistakes and keep electing the same commissioners that create the circus. Be thoughtful upon this election season and vote for those that do not have any ties to the current elected officials especially the same gang of 3.
It’s time to start thinking about electing a Strong Mayor for Coral Gables. Without any ties to special interest.
If not, then let the circus continue. But don’t complain.
Votes for Néstor Menéndez and Nikki Whiting are votes to continue the circus.
They are openly supported by Vince Lago.
We definitely need to learn from our mistakes and not just complain about the disturbing situation in which our City finds itself.
Melissa Castro has listened to the residents, represented us well and has earned our votes.