Eight months after Coral Gables raised greens fees by up to 40 percent and approved a nearly $970,000 contract to restore Granada Golf Course, a University of Miami student’s widely viewed Instagram video criticizing the course’s condition has prompted city officials to defend the effort.
The video, posted Oct. 27 by finance student Max Paksima, has attracted more than 63,000 views. It shows worn greens, patchy fairways and damaged flags at the city-owned course, which Paksima once considered one of his favorite places to play.
The criticism reached the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board on Nov. 12, when Community Recreation Director Fred Couceyro acknowledged inconsistent results from maintenance contractor BrightView. He said the company had brought in a new superintendent and confirmed that the city would seek competitive bids for its next maintenance contract.
A golfer’s critical review
In the Instagram video, Paksima, who posts under @paksgolf, takes viewers around Granada for the second installment of his series, “Playing the Worst Course in Miami.”
He recalls playing the nine-hole course frequently when he first moved to Miami and enjoying its atmosphere. But he questions how its condition has changed, pointing to damaged greens, deteriorating flags and fairways marked by patches of grass, sand and mud.
At one point, Paksima recalls a period when a green had become so damaged that the course placed a flag in the fairway, forcing golfers to putt through unusually long grass.
“The city is not doing a good job of taking care of this place,” he said.
Paksima also criticized the condition of the greens while mistakenly attributing responsibility for the course to the City of Miami. Granada is operated by Coral Gables.
His review was not entirely negative. He praised the employees, describing the pro shop staff as friendly and welcoming.
The video also includes an interview with an unidentified course employee, whom Paksima describes as a golf professional. The employee questioned the city’s spending priorities, saying approximately $550,000 had gone toward rain shelters rather than improvements to greens and fairways.
A $970,000 attempt to restore the course
The criticism comes amid one of Granada’s most significant operational changes in years.
As the Gazette reported in March, commissioners unanimously approved a $969,478 contract with BrightView Holdings LLC for a one-year maintenance pilot, bypassing the usual competitive bidding process.
The contract included approximately $818,000 for maintenance services and $150,000 for renovating the course’s tee boxes.
City officials said the intervention was necessary because Granada, which opened in 1923 and is Florida’s oldest operating public nine-hole golf course, was handling more than 67,000 rounds annually. That amounted to more than 183 rounds a day, a level officials said the turf could not sustain.
The commission also raised greens fees by 36 to 40 percent beginning in April and restructured memberships, aiming to reduce annual play to approximately 50,000 rounds.
BrightView, which maintains the nearby Biltmore Golf Course, was selected partly because it could share equipment and personnel between the properties.
The city subsequently began improvements. In May, Granada closed temporarily while BrightView started tee-box work, aeration, sod replacement and weed management.
But Couceyro told the parks board that results have remained inconsistent. He said a new superintendent was overseeing the maintenance operation and that the city would proceed with competitive bidding when the pilot agreement expires in April.
Fewer rounds, higher revenue
Couceyro pushed back against suggestions that the course was losing its appeal.
Revenue has increased over the past four or five months, he told the board, even as Granada has recorded approximately 1,200 fewer rounds per month.
He attributed the revenue increase partly to a shift in the type of play, with more paid rounds and fewer rounds used through memberships.
The drop in play is largely consistent with the city’s original objective. Reducing annual rounds from 67,000 to 50,000 would mean approximately 1,400 fewer rounds per month.
The higher fees also help explain how revenue could increase while the number of rounds falls, although the figures presented at the meeting do not establish how much of the increase came from pricing rather than changes in usage.
Granada’s declining play therefore cannot be treated solely as evidence of dissatisfied golfers. Reducing wear on the course was a central purpose of the March restructuring.
Whether that reduction has produced the improvements in turf conditions that the city anticipated is a separate question.
A separate $542,000 shelter project
The shelter expenditure mentioned in Paksima’s video is supported by city procurement records, although the employee’s account misstated its timing.
Commissioners approved a $541,841.21 construction contract with PF Management and Construction LLC in July to replace nine rain shelters throughout Granada.
The project followed years of requests from golfers and residents for additional protection during storms. The city announced that work would begin Nov. 2, with construction proceeding in phases while the course remained open.
The shelter project is separate from BrightView’s maintenance contract. City records do not establish that shelter funding was diverted from improvements to the course’s playing surfaces.
Another contract decision approaches
Granada remains one of Coral Gables’ most heavily used recreational facilities, and city officials have emphasized the need to balance public access, revenue and the course’s long-term condition.
The restructuring has reduced play and, according to Couceyro, increased revenue. But the maintenance concerns highlighted in Paksima’s video and acknowledged by the recreation director remain unresolved.
With BrightView’s pilot agreement scheduled to expire in April, the coming competitive bidding process will give the city an opportunity to assess the contractor’s performance and decide how Granada will be maintained in the years ahead.










