Coral Gables will have a Christmas tree lot at the Baptist Church at Granada Boulevard and U.S. 1 this holiday season, preserving a tradition that appeared to be ending after 34 years. But the trees will be sold under a new operator: the Boys & Girls Clubs of Miami-Dade, replacing the business owned by a former Coral Gables fire captain.
A white tent, chain-link fence and Christmas tree sale banner went up this week at the church property. The city confirmed that sales are scheduled to begin Saturday, Nov. 21.
City Manager Peter Iglesias authorized the operation through an administrative special permit, according to a signed memorandum. The City Commission is expected to consider ratification of the permit at its Dec. 15 meeting.
The reopening follows a contentious Oct. 27 commission discussion about the previous operator, Firefighters Christmas Trees. Commissioners deferred its permit application amid concerns about the business’s charitable contributions, and owner Paul Boutin subsequently withdrew it.
What the city objected to in October
As the Gazette reported Oct. 29, commissioners questioned whether the longtime Christmas tree operation complied with city requirements that proceeds from seasonal sales be used for charitable purposes.
Boutin, a former Coral Gables fire captain, operated a for-profit business that paid the Coral Gables Firefighters Benevolent Association a flat fee for use of its name. The business also donated trees to charitable organizations, but city officials said they had believed cash proceeds from sales were supporting charities.
Mayor Vince Lago questioned the arrangement, including the use of the firefighters’ name and the fact that many beneficiaries of donated trees were outside Coral Gables.
City staff offered Boutin an opportunity to propose cash contributions, identify a percentage of proceeds for charitable purposes and clarify the operation’s signage. He withdrew his application after the commission deferred a decision.
The new arrangement identifies the Boys & Girls Clubs, a nonprofit organization, as the operator of the Coral Gables lot under an agreement with Coral Gables Baptist Church. The city says proceeds will support the organization’s youth programs.
According to Iglesias’ memorandum, the nonprofit approached the city after the October meeting. Staff subsequently worked with the organization and the church to preserve the longstanding holiday tradition.
The memorandum credits the Boys & Girls Clubs with more than 40 years of Christmas tree sales at its Hank Kline Club in Miami. It says proceeds from the new Coral Gables location will benefit that club’s after-school programs, homework assistance, STEM education, sports, mentoring and summer camps.
Iglesias said the city received documentation of the organization’s tax-exempt status, liability insurance, agreement with the church and intended use of proceeds.
An unanswered question about the earlier vendor
The October controversy began with an application from a separate Christmas tree seller.
Assistant City Manager Caroline Vester told commissioners Oct. 27 that the applicant wanted to operate on an open lot across from Carver Elementary School. Staff determined that the applicant did not qualify under the city’s charitable-sales requirements because it was operating as a business.
Vester said the applicant had previously been located “at a property with the Boys and Girls Club” that was no longer available to it.
The application prompted staff to examine other Christmas tree operations in Coral Gables, including the longstanding sales at the Baptist Church.
That history raises an unresolved question about the replacement operator.
The Boys & Girls Clubs has its own longstanding Christmas tree fundraiser at the Hank Kline Club, and its 2026 holiday announcement says that lot will open again Monday, Nov. 23.
Vester did not identify the commercial vendor that sought the Carver Elementary location or specify where it previously sold trees. It is unclear whether that business had any involvement in the Hank Kline fundraiser.
The distinction matters because the involvement of a for-profit operator and the distribution of charitable proceeds were central concerns in the October debate.
Although the city identifies the Boys & Girls Clubs as the new operator, the memorandum does not establish who will handle day-to-day sales at the Baptist Church, purchase the trees or receive the revenue before expenses and charitable distributions.
Another question is whether the proceeds will benefit Coral Gables. Lago had argued that the original operation should benefit organizations within the city. The Hank Kline Club, which the city identifies as the beneficiary of the new sales, is located on Southwest 32nd Avenue in Miami, outside Coral Gables city limits.
Where to buy trees
The new lot is scheduled to open Saturday, Nov. 21, at Coral Gables Baptist Church, 5501 Granada Blvd.
The city lists operating hours of 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. daily, with reduced hours of 9 a.m. to noon on Thanksgiving Day.
The Boys & Girls Clubs’ separate Hank Kline fundraiser, at 2805 SW 32nd Ave., is scheduled to open Monday, Nov. 23.
Firefighters Christmas Trees finds a new home
Boutin’s business, meanwhile, has relocated to Palmetto Bay.
The Firefighters Christmas Trees website directs customers to Santa’s Tree Farm at 7500 SW 152nd St., across from Coral Reef Park. The new location opened Nov. 18.
“Same trees. Same family tradition. New home for the season,” the business announces.
Boutin declined to comment on the relocation or the Boys & Girls Clubs taking over his former location.
It remains unclear whether the tree donations Boutin previously made to Coral Gables organizations and residents will continue under the new arrangement.
The city has preserved a place for Christmas tree sales at the Baptist Church, but the commission will still have to consider ratification of the permit, and questions about the new operation’s financial arrangements remain unanswered.










