By Coral Gables Gazette staff
After weeks of disagreement over how to mark the one-year anniversary of the Oct. 7, 2023, attacks, the Coral Gables City Commission agreed Tuesday to forgo symbolic displays on the anniversary itself and instead hold a single interfaith event on Monday, Oct. 27 in the City Hall courtyard.
The shift came after significant resident backlash to a proposal in September to light City Hall in blue and white and display banners. Some members of the faith community also could not participate on Oct. 7 due to a Jewish holiday, and commissioners said they had heard concerns that holding a tribute while the war was still ongoing risked appearing to take a political position. Those factors, combined with public objections, led the city to pause the original plan and seek a broader approach.
Commission seeks clarity after postponed plans
Tuesday’s discussion began with acknowledgment that the postponement caused confusion and frustration. Commissioner Melissa Castro, who placed the item on the agenda, said residents still did not understand why earlier plans were halted or what the commission intended to do in their place.
“I don’t know where the rest of my colleagues stand on this, but giving clear guidance to residents now would be beneficial,” Castro said.
Mayor Vince Lago opened with prepared remarks praising the recently announced peace agreement between Israel and Hamas and crediting former President Donald Trump. He said he did not want to re-litigate “lights or banners,” which he characterized as having generated social-media soundbites. His comments echoed earlier disputes over whether symbolic displays were appropriate or unifying.
Interfaith ceremony replaces lighting and banners
As the discussion evolved, commissioners aligned around hosting an interfaith ceremony on October 27 and confirmed that it will replace the previously proposed Oct. 7 lighting and banner display. The banner the commission had approved earlier will now be used on Oct. 27, and City Hall will be lit in red, white, and blue rather than the blue and white associated with Israel. Commissioners said the revised approach would include voices from multiple faith traditions and reflect losses “on all sides” rather than signaling a foreign policy stance.
Several commissioners emphasized that the change in format was driven more by local divisions than by international developments, though the timing of the peace agreement made the transition more logical.
Emphasis on unity and multifaith participation
Vice Mayor Rhonda Anderson called the interfaith format “the most unifying way forward” and said it should involve clergy from different traditions rather than a single perspective. Commissioner Ariel Fernandez agreed, adding, “If this is about healing, it needs to reflect everyone who lives in this city.”
The commission directed City Manager Peter Iglesias to work directly with local clergy to finalize the program. The previously discussed Oct. 7 observance — including building lighting in Israeli colors — will not move forward.
Tensions surface but consensus holds
The conversation briefly grew tense when Castro said the mayor had politicized the issue during a radio interview by criticizing her and Fernandez while overlooking their prior cooperation. Commissioner Richard Lara defended the mayor and accused Castro of using the topic for political effect.
This Post Has 5 Comments
Unless they have a monetary interest in some way, the commissioners proposing the commemoration of an anniversary of an international conflict with which the city has nothing to do is against the most basic civic principles, and holding an event that reflects a religious belief goes against the constitutional principles on which this country is founded. The commissioners are corrupting civic principles.
But what about the poor Palestinians that lost their lives?What about the children & the people that tried to give them aid that were killed.
Will you have a flag for all their lives lost ! Their country in shambles
I’m catholic too & this war was not about religion It was about evil power. Calm down all of you & honor all the fallen!
Agreed. It’s about power and land
Agreed 👍
And to then hold an interfaith event to only honor victims of one faith/ethno faith and not commemorate the nearly 6000 times more death (68k) of Palestinians is tone deaf. Hope they do invite all faiths if they do this at all and let them speak freely also of the sheer loss
Of life before and after 10/7 even though there is a ceasefire, Israel has killed over 30 Palestinians already and detained innocents including children. You cease, we fire.
Don’t get involved in foreign politics as a city. When the residents speak as a majority in 3 meetings and ask you stop and make all feel welcome.
No flag of another country for politics ever.
To then put a flag of Israel with America in the Mayor’s window and tagging on social the Israel embassy, magazines and PACs. It’s unethical and unnecessary.
We see you and what capitulation looks like.
What a mess! Politicians wanting to divide rather than being honest on their stand is not acceptable and only make matters worse… the narrative of Israel being first ( under the disguise of making it about faith) is dishonest….It is also not doing service to the people of different faith and keeping people not critical think about the issue so there’s a resolution to this human tragedy.
I hope the politicians do better for themselves and their country and overall for humanity